A great coil is the one that matches up perfectly to the detector you are using, that suits the ground conditions you are working, and is optimised for the gold that is still sitting in the ground. So, I know a 5000 and the 12" Evo is a great combo a lot of the time, but isn't going to be great everywhere. Very deep ground you want something bigger, and if there's HV power lines or electric fences about, you'll need a DD coil or you simply leave that area.
I guess when it comes to coils for the GPX's, you can put them in 3 groups:
1. Early pre-gpx coils.
These are traditional wound coils, some using Litz wire, others not, that were optimised for the detectors that were out at the time. Examples are Minelab Super Gold Search coils, Coiltek terracotta monos & DDs, and some early Nugget Finder fiberglass coils. A lot of these would be hit and miss as to how compatible they are with GPX detectors, especially the 5000 which is a little more fussy on coil specs with its 8 timings.
2. Post-gpx traditional wound coils.
These are all the coils that were wound to be compatible with the GPX series, particularly once the 5000 came out. Minelab Commander, Minelab GP series DD's, Nugget Finder Advantage series, Coiltek Goldstalker (in particular the Blitz as it used Litz wire), and all Detech coils. These coils were basically wound to a tight specification to ensure they work well with the GPX5000, so you'll find very little performance difference between similar sizes - apart from mechanical build and quality differences.
3. Flat/spiral wound coils.
These are the new generation of coils, which Dave NT has covered pretty thoroughly. The performance differences between the Elites, Evos, and Detech Ultra Sensing are hair splitting, that I think it's almost not worth worrying about. The main differences are weight, build quality and of course price. Evo's being most expensive, then Elites then the Detech's are just under. Size for size, Evo's are the lightest, especially the spoked versions, then the Elites and Detechs are neck n neck.
Hope that helps clear up a few things Daz.