I don't think you were too harsh on Jamesgold Casper. You weren't rude or offensive, and your advice on research and pointing the way to Geovic was sound and helpful.
I only found my first small gold nugget using a metal detector last week- A full two years after starting into the hobby and joining the forum. For a while I did what most people do- buy some maps and go where everybody else goes, and has gone, for week after week, year after year, detecting the same old tired ground, over and over, and over again. Along the way I learned about my detector, about hot rocks, false signals, EMI, clay domes, geology, and that in those places especially, there's more junk than there is gold.
I have pigheadedly continued on with a large coil on a GPX5000, determined in my search to find a large nugget to name after my wife. Many times I have been tempted to strap on a small coil and look for "sub-grammers", but being true to myself I knew that I would never be happy simply joining the race to the bottom, whereby it has to be easy gold to the point of putting on ridiculously ever smaller/ more sensitive coils to find the most ridiculous crumbs called gold ever seen through a magnifying glass.
The turning point for me was one night when I logged in and saw something that Reg wrote, as ever in his blunt and forthright way. Something along the lines of "most people detect, very few prospect". It ate at me at first (maybe your reply to Jamesgold will eat at him too), and it would have been easy to just hate Reg Wilson like so many of the green eyed monsters in the prospecting world do. But, I thought about it, and asked myself why it was that it hurt me so much, and it still ate at me. The answer of course, as is often the case when somebody says something that cuts deep, is that it was true.
I have made an effort from then on to learn to prospect and not just detect. I don't buy maps anymore, I use Geovic & National Map, I read mining surveyor reports from the 1800's and 1900's, I find articles in Trove, and I have spent countless hours reading geological papers, and trying to understand why it is that gold occurs where it does. For the first time last week I went somewhere based purely on my own research, based only on what I have learned over the last two years. And bugger me if I didn't find a 1.5g tiddler, with a 25" DDX NF of all coils. The sweetest part is, there isn't a mineshaft, unfilled hole or evidence of anyone having ever fossicked, detected, or prospected there before.
You pointed James in the right direction, and nobody deserves an "X marks the spot" answer :Y:
-D.S